신사고운동을 실증하는 실험? In 1988 Rene Peoc’h's experiment in which day-old imprinted chicks influenced a robot to come to their cage.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/110mo9r/in_1988_rene_peochs_experiment_in_which_dayold/
Archived post. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.
A) The control experiment when the cage was empty. B) Experiment in which day-old chicks imprinted with the robot were kept in the cage.
https://www.scientificexploration.org/docs/9/jse_09_2_peoch.pdf
seems there are a lot of open questions.. The robot has a candle and it only worked if that was on .. also only if done in the morning. And these "random number" generator are not always true random.
Well who knows if you don't use scientific methods to find out .. russia did some experiments with kitten to test the connection from the mother over distance. And there is at least the possibility of quantum effects within the endoplasmic reticulum of cells.
There is the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Consciousness_Project quite interesting.
So, we have a robot that moves randomly and its movement is controlled by a random numbers generator (RNG) that is installed in another room (not on the robot itself) and can be placed “inside a lead box, a Faraday box, a container full of water, etc., which can shield it against various types of electromagnetic interference” (which shielding was actually applied in this experiment is not specified by the way). So, if the chicks change the movement of the robot which movement is controlled by the RNG do they actually affect the shielded(presumably) RNG in another room they don’t know of? Why the chicks’ will does not work during the day? Why it works only when the candle is of certain length? A really impressive result would be to observe that the robot to move against the RNG generated numbers i. e the RNG “tells” the robot to go forward but it goes backwards (or any other direction) due to the will of the chicks. That would be very interesting.
ok so we have a robot that clearly is designed to turn when it meets an obstacle. In the first image the obstacles are the walls. Then you add chickens that presumably take over the left half of the enclosure. If they are not themselves enclosed in the enclosure they will wander but be afraid of the robot. The pattern in B is totally consistent with a robot avoiding chicks and the chicks avoiding the robot. And you idiots want to claim that it is Psychokinesis?!!! You can't even do pseudo science well!!!
My first thought was the same. But in the experiment the chicks were not in the enclosure, they were in a cage on the side of the table so they couldn't affect the robot's movements
they couldn't affect the robot's movements
So why hasn't this experiment been replicated? Have you tried it? It's fake. The department in which the experiment was allegedly conducted was closed down.
It is funny. First you tried to point out a flaw in the experiment (assuming wrongly that the chicks were inside the enclosure, although you swear to have read the experiment...). Then, as soon as you realized your point was wrong, you jumped immediately to "the experiment was never replicated", abandoning your first line of thought in no time.... I'm not saying the experiment is 100% right, I'm just saying your attitude suggest a personal bias, that isn't also very scientific...I would love to see the experiment being replicated as well.
Comments
Post a Comment