로스차일드-이코노미스트 민주주의 지수를 보고 든 생각 - 민주주의 최상위 국가들이 경제, 복지 모두 최상위국가들인 것은 우연일까?

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index#List_by_country

List by country

[edit]

The following table shows each nation's score over the years. The regions are assigned by the Economist Intelligence Unit, and may differ from conventional classifications (for example, Turkey is grouped in Western Europe).

Region2023 rankCountryRegime type2023202220212020201920182017201620152014201320122011201020082006
North America13 CanadaFull democracy8.698.888.879.249.229.159.159.159.089.089.089.089.089.089.079.07
29 United StatesFlawed democracy7.857.857.857.927.967.967.987.988.058.118.118.118.118.188.228.22
Western Europe19 AustriaFull democracy8.288.208.078.168.298.298.428.418.548.548.488.628.498.498.498.69
36 BelgiumFlawed democracy7.647.647.517.517.647.787.787.777.937.938.058.058.058.058.168.15
37 CyprusFlawed democracy7.387.387.437.567.597.597.597.657.537.407.297.297.297.297.707.60
6 DenmarkFull democracy9.289.289.099.159.229.229.229.209.119.119.389.529.529.529.529.52
5 FinlandFull democracy9.309.299.279.209.259.149.039.039.039.039.039.069.069.199.259.25
23 FranceFull democracy8.078.077.997.998.127.807.807.927.928.047.927.887.777.778.078.07
12 GermanyFull democracy8.808.808.678.678.688.688.618.638.648.648.318.348.348.388.828.82
21 GreeceFull democracy8.147.977.567.397.437.297.297.237.457.457.657.657.657.928.138.13
3 IcelandFull democracy9.459.529.189.379.589.589.589.509.589.589.659.659.659.659.659.71
7 IrelandFull democracy9.199.139.009.059.249.159.159.158.858.728.688.568.568.799.019.01
34 ItalyFlawed democracy7.697.697.687.747.527.717.987.987.987.857.857.747.747.837.987.73
11 LuxembourgFull democracy8.818.818.688.688.818.818.818.818.888.888.888.888.888.889.109.10
28 MaltaFlawed democracy7.937.707.577.687.958.218.158.398.398.398.288.288.288.288.398.39
9 NetherlandsFull democracy9.009.008.888.969.018.898.898.808.928.928.848.998.998.999.539.66
1 NorwayFull democracy9.819.819.759.819.879.879.879.939.939.939.939.939.809.809.689.55
31 PortugalFlawed democracy7.757.957.827.908.037.847.847.867.797.797.657.927.818.028.058.16
23 SpainFull democracy8.078.077.948.128.298.088.088.308.308.058.028.028.028.168.458.34
4 SwedenFull democracy9.399.399.269.269.399.399.399.399.459.739.739.739.509.509.889.88
8 SwitzerlandFull democracy9.149.148.908.839.039.039.039.099.099.099.099.099.099.099.159.02
102 TurkeyHybrid regime4.334.354.354.484.094.374.885.045.125.125.635.765.735.735.695.70
18 United KingdomFull democracy8.288.288.108.548.528.538.538.368.318.318.318.218.168.168.158.08
Central and Eastern Europe66 AlbaniaFlawed democracy6.286.416.116.085.895.985.985.915.915.675.675.675.815.865.915.91
84 ArmeniaHybrid regime5.425.635.495.355.544.794.113.884.004.134.024.094.094.094.094.15
130 AzerbaijanAuthoritarian2.802.872.682.682.752.652.652.652.712.833.063.153.153.153.193.31
151 BelarusAuthoritarian1.991.992.412.592.483.133.133.543.623.693.043.043.163.343.343.34
94 Bosnia and HerzegovinaHybrid regime5.005.005.044.844.864.984.874.874.834.785.025.115.245.325.705.78
62 BulgariaFlawed democracy6.416.536.646.717.037.037.037.017.146.736.836.726.786.847.027.10
58 CroatiaFlawed democracy6.506.506.506.506.576.576.636.756.936.936.936.936.736.817.047.04
26 Czech RepublicFlawed democracy7.977.977.747.677.697.697.627.827.947.948.068.198.198.198.198.17
27 EstoniaFlawed democracy7.967.967.847.847.907.977.797.857.857.747.617.617.617.687.687.74
89 GeorgiaHybrid regime5.205.205.125.315.425.505.935.935.885.825.955.534.744.594.624.90
50 HungaryFlawed democracy6.726.646.506.566.636.636.646.726.846.906.966.967.047.217.447.53
120 KazakhstanAuthoritarian3.083.083.083.142.942.943.063.063.063.173.062.953.243.303.453.62
109 KyrgyzstanAuthoritarian3.703.623.624.214.895.115.114.935.335.244.694.694.344.314.054.08
38 LatviaFlawed democracy7.387.377.317.247.497.387.257.317.377.487.057.057.057.057.237.37
39 LithuaniaFlawed democracy7.317.317.187.137.507.507.417.477.547.547.547.247.247.247.367.43
68 MoldovaFlawed democracy6.236.236.105.785.755.855.946.016.356.326.326.326.326.336.506.50
52 MontenegroFlawed democracy6.676.456.025.775.655.745.695.726.015.945.946.056.156.276.436.57
73 North MacedoniaFlawed democracy6.036.106.035.895.975.875.575.236.026.256.166.166.166.166.216.33
42 PolandFlawed democracy7.187.046.806.856.626.676.676.837.097.477.127.127.127.057.307.30
60 RomaniaFlawed democracy6.456.456.436.406.496.386.446.626.686.686.546.546.546.607.067.06
144 RussiaAuthoritarian2.222.283.243.313.112.943.173.243.313.393.593.743.924.264.485.02
64 SerbiaFlawed democracy6.336.336.366.226.416.416.416.576.716.716.676.336.336.336.496.62
44 SlovakiaFlawed democracy7.077.077.036.977.177.107.167.297.297.357.357.357.357.357.337.40
32 SloveniaFlawed democracy7.757.757.547.547.507.507.507.517.577.577.887.887.767.697.967.96
155 TajikistanAuthoritarian1.941.941.941.941.931.931.931.891.952.372.512.512.512.512.452.45
162 TurkmenistanAuthoritarian1.661.661.661.721.721.721.721.831.831.831.721.721.721.721.721.83
91 UkraineHybrid regime5.065.425.575.815.905.695.695.705.705.425.845.915.946.306.946.94
149 UzbekistanAuthoritarian2.122.122.122.122.012.011.951.951.952.451.721.721.741.741.741.85
Latin America and the Caribbean54 ArgentinaFlawed democracy6.626.856.816.957.027.026.966.967.026.846.846.846.846.846.636.63
106 BoliviaHybrid regime4.204.514.655.084.845.705.495.635.755.795.795.845.845.926.155.98
51 BrazilFlawed democracy6.686.786.866.926.866.976.866.906.967.387.127.127.127.127.387.38
25 ChileFlawed democracy7.988.227.928.288.087.977.847.787.847.807.807.547.547.677.897.89
55 ColombiaFlawed democracy6.556.726.487.047.136.966.676.676.626.556.556.636.636.556.546.40
17 Costa RicaFull democracy8.298.298.078.168.138.077.887.887.968.038.038.108.108.048.048.04
135 CubaAuthoritarian2.652.652.592.842.843.003.313.463.523.523.523.523.523.523.523.52
61 Dominican RepublicFlawed democracy6.446.396.456.326.546.546.666.676.676.676.746.496.206.206.206.13
85 EcuadorHybrid regime5.415.695.716.136.336.276.025.815.875.875.875.785.725.775.645.64
96 El SalvadorHybrid regime4.715.065.725.906.155.966.436.646.646.536.536.476.476.476.406.22
100 GuatemalaHybrid regime4.474.684.624.975.265.605.865.925.925.815.815.885.886.056.076.07
67 GuyanaFlawed democracy6.266.346.256.016.156.676.466.256.055.916.056.056.056.056.126.15
129 HaitiAuthoritarian2.812.813.484.224.574.914.034.023.943.823.943.964.004.004.194.19
95 HondurasHybrid regime4.985.155.105.365.425.635.725.925.845.845.845.845.845.766.186.25
45 JamaicaFlawed democracy7.067.137.137.136.967.027.297.397.397.397.397.397.137.217.217.34
90 MexicoHybrid regime5.145.255.576.076.096.196.416.476.556.686.916.906.936.936.786.67
143 NicaraguaAuthoritarian2.262.502.693.603.553.634.664.815.265.325.465.565.565.736.075.68
48 PanamaFlawed democracy6.916.916.857.187.057.057.087.137.197.087.087.087.087.157.357.35
74 ParaguayFlawed democracy6.005.895.866.186.246.246.316.276.336.266.266.266.406.406.406.16
77 PeruHybrid regime5.815.926.096.536.606.606.496.656.586.546.546.476.596.406.316.11
49 SurinameFlawed democracy6.886.956.826.826.986.986.766.776.776.776.776.656.656.656.586.52
43 Trinidad and TobagoFlawed democracy7.167.167.167.167.167.167.047.107.106.996.996.997.167.167.217.18
15 UruguayFull democracy8.668.918.858.618.388.388.128.178.178.178.178.178.178.108.087.96
142 VenezuelaAuthoritarian2.312.232.112.762.883.163.874.685.005.075.075.155.085.185.345.42
Asia and Australasia167 AfghanistanAuthoritarian0.260.320.322.852.852.972.552.552.772.772.482.482.482.483.023.06
14 AustraliaFull democracy8.668.718.908.969.099.099.099.019.019.019.139.229.229.229.099.09
75 BangladeshHybrid regime5.875.995.995.995.885.575.435.735.735.785.865.865.865.875.526.11
81 BhutanHybrid regime5.545.545.715.715.305.305.084.934.934.874.824.654.574.684.302.62
121 CambodiaAuthoritarian3.053.182.903.103.533.593.634.274.274.784.604.964.874.874.874.77
148 ChinaAuthoritarian2.121.942.212.272.263.323.103.183.143.003.003.003.143.143.042.97
80 FijiHybrid regime5.555.555.615.725.855.855.855.645.695.613.613.673.673.625.115.66
88 Hong KongHybrid regime5.245.285.605.576.026.156.316.426.506.466.426.425.925.925.856.03
41 IndiaFlawed democracy7.187.046.916.616.907.237.237.817.747.927.697.527.307.287.807.68
56 IndonesiaFlawed democracy6.536.716.716.306.486.396.396.977.036.956.826.766.536.536.346.41
16 JapanFull democracy8.408.338.158.137.997.997.887.997.968.088.088.088.088.088.258.15
159 LaosAuthoritarian1.711.771.771.772.142.372.372.372.212.212.212.322.102.102.102.10
40 MalaysiaFlawed democracy7.297.307.247.197.166.886.546.546.436.496.496.416.196.196.365.98
59 MongoliaFlawed democracy6.486.356.426.486.506.506.506.626.626.626.516.356.236.366.606.60
166 MyanmarAuthoritarian0.850.741.023.043.553.833.834.204.143.052.762.351.771.771.771.77
98 NepalHybrid regime4.604.494.415.225.285.185.184.864.774.774.774.164.244.244.053.42
2 New ZealandFull democracy9.619.619.379.259.269.269.269.269.269.269.269.269.269.269.199.01
165 North KoreaAuthoritarian1.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.081.080.861.03
118 PakistanAuthoritarian3.254.134.314.314.254.174.264.334.404.644.644.574.554.554.463.92
72 Papua New GuineaFlawed democracy6.035.976.106.106.036.036.036.036.036.036.366.326.326.546.546.54
53 PhilippinesFlawed democracy6.666.736.626.566.646.716.716.946.846.776.416.306.126.126.126.48
69 SingaporeFlawed democracy6.186.226.236.036.026.386.326.386.146.035.925.885.895.895.895.89
22 South KoreaFull democracy8.098.038.168.018.008.008.007.927.978.068.068.138.068.118.017.88
70 Sri LankaFlawed democracy6.176.476.146.146.276.196.486.486.425.695.695.756.586.646.616.58
10 TaiwanFull democracy8.928.998.998.947.737.737.737.797.837.657.577.577.467.527.827.82
63 ThailandFlawed democracy6.356.676.046.046.324.634.634.925.095.396.256.556.556.556.815.67
46 East TimorFlawed democracy7.067.067.067.067.197.197.197.247.247.247.247.167.227.227.226.41
136 VietnamAuthoritarian2.622.732.942.943.083.083.083.383.533.413.292.892.962.942.532.75
Middle East and North Africa110 AlgeriaAuthoritarian3.663.663.773.774.013.503.563.563.953.833.833.833.443.443.323.17
139 BahrainAuthoritarian2.522.522.522.492.552.712.712.792.792.872.872.532.923.493.383.53
127 EgyptAuthoritarian2.932.932.932.933.063.363.363.313.183.163.274.563.953.073.893.90
153 IranAuthoritarian1.961.961.952.202.382.452.452.342.161.981.981.981.981.942.832.93
128 IraqAuthoritarian2.883.133.513.623.744.064.094.084.084.234.104.104.034.004.004.01
30 IsraelFlawed democracy7.807.937.977.847.867.797.797.857.777.637.537.537.537.487.487.28
122 JordanAuthoritarian3.043.173.493.623.933.933.873.963.863.763.763.763.893.743.933.92
114 KuwaitAuthoritarian3.503.833.913.803.933.853.853.853.853.783.783.783.743.883.393.09
112 LebanonAuthoritarian3.563.643.844.164.364.634.724.864.865.125.055.055.325.825.625.82
157 LibyaAuthoritarian1.782.061.951.952.022.192.322.252.253.804.825.153.551.942.001.84
93 MoroccoHybrid regime5.045.045.045.045.104.994.874.774.664.004.074.073.833.793.883.90
119 OmanAuthoritarian3.123.123.003.003.063.043.043.043.043.153.263.263.262.862.982.77
115 PalestineAuthoritarian3.473.863.943.833.894.394.464.494.574.724.804.804.975.445.836.01
111 QatarAuthoritarian3.653.653.653.243.193.193.193.183.183.183.183.183.183.092.922.78
150 Saudi ArabiaAuthoritarian2.082.082.082.081.931.931.931.931.931.821.821.711.771.841.901.92
158 SudanAuthoritarian1.762.472.472.542.702.152.152.372.372.542.542.382.382.422.812.90
163 SyriaAuthoritarian1.431.431.431.431.431.431.431.431.431.741.861.631.992.312.182.36
82 TunisiaHybrid regime5.515.515.996.596.726.416.326.406.726.315.765.675.532.792.963.06
125 United Arab EmiratesAuthoritarian3.012.902.902.702.762.762.692.752.752.642.522.582.582.522.602.42
154 YemenAuthoritarian1.951.951.951.951.951.952.072.072.242.792.793.122.572.642.952.98
Sub-Saharan Africa107 AngolaHybrid regime4.183.963.373.663.723.623.623.403.353.353.353.353.323.323.352.41
97 BeninHybrid regime4.684.284.194.585.095.745.615.675.725.655.876.006.066.176.066.16
33 BotswanaFlawed democracy7.737.737.737.627.817.817.817.877.877.877.987.857.637.637.477.60
133 Burkina FasoAuthoritarian2.733.083.843.734.044.754.754.704.704.094.153.523.593.593.603.72
147 BurundiAuthoritarian2.132.132.132.142.152.332.332.402.493.333.413.604.014.014.514.51
35 Cape VerdeFlawed democracy7.657.657.657.657.787.887.887.947.817.817.927.927.927.947.817.43
138 CameroonAuthoritarian2.562.562.562.772.853.283.613.463.663.413.413.443.413.413.463.27
164 Central African RepublicAuthoritarian1.181.351.431.321.321.521.521.611.571.491.491.991.821.821.861.61
161 ChadAuthoritarian1.671.671.671.551.611.611.501.501.501.501.501.621.621.521.521.65
123 ComorosAuthoritarian3.043.203.203.093.153.713.713.713.713.523.523.523.523.413.583.90
131 Republic of the CongoAuthoritarian2.792.792.793.113.113.313.252.912.912.892.892.892.892.892.943.19
105 Ivory CoastHybrid regime4.224.224.224.114.054.153.933.813.313.533.253.253.083.023.273.38
160 Democratic Republic of the CongoAuthoritarian1.681.481.401.131.131.491.611.932.111.751.831.922.152.152.282.76
134 DjiboutiAuthoritarian2.702.742.742.712.772.872.762.832.902.992.962.742.682.202.372.37
156 Equatorial GuineaAuthoritarian1.921.921.921.921.921.921.811.701.771.661.771.831.771.842.192.09
152 EritreaAuthoritarian1.972.032.032.152.372.372.372.372.372.442.402.402.342.312.312.31
132 EswatiniAuthoritarian2.783.013.083.083.143.033.033.033.093.093.203.203.262.903.042.93
116 EthiopiaAuthoritarian3.373.173.303.383.443.353.423.603.833.723.833.723.793.684.524.72
146 GabonAuthoritarian2.183.403.403.543.613.613.613.743.763.763.763.563.483.293.002.72
101 GambiaHybrid regime4.474.474.414.494.334.314.062.912.973.053.313.313.383.384.194.39
65 GhanaFlawed democracy6.306.436.506.506.636.636.696.756.866.336.336.026.026.025.355.35
145 GuineaAuthoritarian2.212.322.283.083.143.143.143.143.143.012.842.792.792.792.092.02
140 Guinea-BissauAuthoritarian2.452.562.752.632.631.981.981.981.931.931.261.431.991.991.992.00
92 KenyaHybrid regime5.055.055.055.055.185.115.115.335.335.135.134.714.714.714.795.08
71 LesothoFlawed democracy6.066.196.306.306.546.646.646.596.596.666.666.666.336.026.296.48
79 LiberiaHybrid regime5.575.435.435.325.455.355.235.314.954.954.954.955.075.075.255.22
87 MadagascarHybrid regime5.265.705.705.705.645.225.115.074.854.424.323.933.933.945.575.82
76 MalawiHybrid regime5.855.915.745.745.505.495.495.555.555.666.006.085.845.845.134.97
137 MaliAuthoritarian2.583.233.483.934.925.415.645.705.705.795.905.126.366.015.875.99
108 MauritaniaHybrid regime4.144.034.033.923.923.823.823.963.964.174.174.174.173.863.913.12
20 MauritiusFull democracy8.148.148.088.148.228.228.228.288.278.178.178.178.048.048.048.04
113 MozambiqueAuthoritarian3.513.513.513.513.653.854.024.024.604.664.774.884.904.905.495.28
57 NamibiaFlawed democracy6.526.526.526.526.436.256.316.316.316.246.246.246.246.236.486.54
141 NigerAuthoritarian2.373.733.223.293.293.763.763.964.624.024.084.164.163.383.413.54
104 NigeriaHybrid regime4.234.234.114.104.124.444.444.503.853.763.773.773.833.473.533.52
117 RwandaAuthoritarian3.303.103.103.103.163.353.193.073.073.253.383.363.253.253.713.82
83 SenegalHybrid regime5.485.725.535.675.816.156.156.216.086.156.156.095.515.275.375.37
103 Sierra LeoneHybrid regime4.325.034.974.864.864.664.664.554.554.564.644.714.514.514.113.57
47 South AfricaFlawed democracy7.057.057.057.057.247.247.247.417.567.827.907.797.797.797.917.91
86 TanzaniaHybrid regime5.355.105.105.105.165.415.475.765.585.775.775.885.645.645.285.18
126 TogoAuthoritarian2.992.992.802.803.303.103.053.323.413.453.453.453.453.452.431.75
99 UgandaHybrid regime4.494.554.484.945.025.205.095.265.225.225.225.165.135.055.035.14
78 ZambiaHybrid regime5.805.805.724.865.095.615.685.996.286.396.266.266.195.685.255.25
124 ZimbabweAuthoritarian3.042.922.923.163.163.163.163.053.052.782.672.672.682.642.532.62

Components

[edit]

The following table shows the five parameters that made up the score of each nation in 2023 and the changes that had occurred since 2022.

Comments

Popular Posts

제임스 코벳: 지역 정부가 곧 세계정부이다 1 / 프랑스, 캐나다도 EU 가입할 수 있어 / 다극화된 세계질서는 신세계질서의 연막술 / 골드만삭스 출신 짐 오닐이 만든 용어 BRICS / 브릭스 국가들이 기술 관료주의, 과두제, 온라인 검열, 사회 신용 시스템, 코로나19 팬데믹, 생물 안보, 지속 가능한 개발 목표 등 모든 것에 동의하는 이유는 '거대한 클럽'에 속해 있기 때문 / 중국이 주도하는 국제은행간통신협회(SWIFT) 대안인 중국은행간결제시스템(CIPS)은 거래의 80%를 SWIFT 네트워크에 의존 / 존 메이너드 케인스의 '뱅코어(Bankor)' 개념은 생산적인 대출을 통해 인프라 투자를 장려하는 것이었으며, 이는 BRICS 국가들의 대출 철학과 유사 / BRICS 국가들이 국제통화기금(IMF)과 같은 '약탈적인 괴물'로부터 세계를 구원할 것이라는 주장과 달리, 아시아인프라투자은행(AIIB)과 신개발은행(NDB) 설립 직후 이들과 세계은행, IMF 간의 제도적 연결고리가 드러났다. IMF 총재 크리스틴 라가르드는 AIIB와의 협력을 약속했다. 세계은행 총재 김용은 AIIB 출범을 축하하며 협력을 약속했다. 신개발은행 총재는 경쟁 관계가 아닌 상호 보완적인 관계임을 밝히며 협력 협정을 체결했다. BRICS 신개발은행 부총재는 IMF 집행 이사로 활동하며 협력과 공동 행동을 약속했다. AIIB와 NDB 설립을 앞두고 '게임의 판도를 완전히 바꿀 것'이라는 기대가 있었지만, 실제로는 기존 시스템과의 협력을 통해 '시스템의 일부'가 되는 것을 목표로 했다. / 유엔은 러시아와 중국이 시행한 격리 및 전염병 통제 조치를 칭찬하며, 유엔이 테러 및 평화 유지에 중심적인 역할을 해야 한다고 주장한다. / 세계 정부 1.0은 국제 연맹, 2.0은 유엔으로 볼 수 있으며, 3.0은 다극화된 세계 질서이다. / 러시아와 중국은 세계주의자들에 맞서 싸우는 것이 아니라, 단지 세계 정부 테이블에 앉을 자리를 놓고 경쟁하는 것이다.